Featured
September 18, 2025

United’s Newark crisis created a once-in-a-decade culture transformation opportunity. Learn why hiring for values during recovery determines whether crisis becomes comeback or just another cycle.

Shelley D. Smith
Founder & CEO of Premier Rapport
Share on:
Blog Image

Sometimes the Worst PR Disaster Creates the Best Culture Transformation Opportunity

Companies that just “fill seats” after a crisis stay broken. T

hey hire for today’s problems instead of tomorrow’s culture. The organizations that actually transform get strategic about who they bring into the building.

When Newark Liberty International spent months as the poster child for airport dysfunction... flight cancellations, passenger chaos, FAA-mandated flight limits.

Most people saw damage control.

I saw the culture transformation opportunity of the decade.

United Airlines announced 2,500 new Newark-area hires.

That’s not just a staffing decision.

It’s a cultural moment. Because those 2,500 people won’t just staff Newark.

They’ll define it.

I’ve spent years helping organizations rebuild after major breakdowns, and I’ve learned something counterintuitive: sometimes public failure creates something most companies never get.

A clean slate moment where everyone understands they’re part of a turnaround mission.

The question isn’t whether they can hire fast enough.

The question is whether they’re hiring the right people to ensure this crisis never happens again.

Why Most Crisis Hiring Fails

Here’s what I’ve observed across cultural turnarounds: organizations that respond to crisis by filling seats stay broken.

They hire for skills, not values. They fill positions, not cultural gaps.

They solve operational issues, not relational dysfunction.

Newark’s summer chaos wasn’t really about understaffing or technical failures.

Those were symptoms. The real issue was cultural dehydration.

What happens when relationship-culture runs dry in high-pressure environments.

Staff shortages and system glitches are operational problems. But when teams don’t communicate effectively, when safety protocols become checkbox exercises instead of shared commitments, when customer service becomes a burden instead of a mission — that’s cultural drought.

I’ve seen this exact pattern in hospitality, manufacturing, defense, family businesses.

The operational failures get the headlines.

The cultural dehydration underneath gets ignored. And then the cycle repeats.

Culture Carriers vs. Position Fillers

The 2,500 new hires could become culture carriers instead of just position fillers.

But only if the organization understands what they’re really hiring for.

Instead of just screening for customer service skills, they need people with genuine customer empathy.

Individuals who see passenger stress as their problem to solve, not just their job to manage.

Rather than checking experience boxes, they need stress-resilient personalities who thrive under pressure and see challenges as collaborative puzzles.

Beyond basic safety compliance, they need safety advocates...people who internalize protocols as protective measures for their community.

Most critically, they need team-first thinkers who understand that individual performance means nothing if the system fails.

This is the same principle that applies when any organization is scaling rapidly while trying to preserve culture.

Every hire during recovery either accelerates transformation or reinforces the old problems. There’s no neutral.

What This Means for Your Organization

You might not be running an airport, but every organization faces moments where hiring strategy determines cultural future.

Maybe you’re scaling rapidly and worried about maintaining culture during growth.

Maybe you’re dealing with high turnover and need to understand what’s really driving people away.

Maybe you’ve had your own version of a Newark summer.

Crisis hiring isn’t about speed, it’s about precision.

The people you bring in during difficult moments become your cultural foundation for the next decade.

Cultural fit isn’t a luxury during turnarounds.

It’s the foundation that makes technical skills actually matter.

The Long Game

The operational recovery happens through logistics, systems, and capacity management.

But the real recovery.

The one that determines whether an organization becomes a case study in transformation or just another company that temporarily fixed its logistics, happens in hiring rooms.

If they get the hiring strategy right, the recovery site doesn’t just stabilize.

It becomes the showcase.

The place where the organization demonstrates what culture can look like when relationship-culture is healthy and flowing.

If they get it wrong?

They’ll be managing the next crisis with the same cultural drought that created this one.

The Question Every Hiring Manager Should Ask

When you’re hiring - whether during crisis recovery or regular growth -are you hiring for today’s job descriptions or tomorrow’s culture?

Are you screening for skills that can be taught or values that drive everything else?

Culture isn’t what happens after you hire the right people.

Culture is what determines who the right people actually are.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you rebuild company culture after a crisis?

Crisis creates a unique window because everyone understands change is needed.

Treat every hire as a culture carrier, not a position filler: screen for values alignment alongside skills, genuine empathy over just experience, stress resilience over just credentials, team-first thinking over individual metrics.

What is the difference between hiring for skills and hiring for culture?

Skills hiring asks “Can they do the job?” Culture hiring asks “Will they thrive here while doing this job?” The distinction matters most during recovery or rapid growth. Culture-aware hiring builds teams where service becomes mission and challenges become collaborative puzzles.

How do you scale culture during rapid hiring?

Precision over speed. Define behavioral patterns and values driving your desired culture, screen for alignment at every stage, use behavioral assessments for values-match, and ensure onboarding connects new hires to cultural narrative — not just procedures.

Why does crisis create a culture transformation opportunity?

Public failure gives organizations a rare clean slate where everyone understands they’re part of a turnaround. This eliminates usual resistance to change. Organizations that leverage this strategically emerge with cultures stronger than pre-crisis.

Take a look at our latest insights

Explore articles, case studies, and resources - crafted to keep you ahead.

Buy this template
$129
Need to customize this template
Explore our premium templates